Table 2

Changes in HRV related to physical treatments for depression other than SSRIs or TCAs.

Measure
Heart Rate
SDNN
SDANN
RMSSD
LF
lnHF
HF
LF/HF
CV
pNN50
Units
bpm
ms
ms
ms
ms2
ms2
ms2
ratio
ratio
percent

Reboxetine short supine










Mean Baseline Value
82.60


18.50
946.00

354



Mean Percent Change
5.6%


-1.6%
-18.9%

21.8%



Number of Comparisons
1


1
1

1



Mean Effect Size
1.32 ns


-0.04 ns
-0.38 ns

0.79 ns



Nefazodone short supine










Mean Baseline Value
75.80
30.08

24.50
864.00

480
2.97
3.80

Mean Percent Change
-5.9%
14.3%

4.1%
-5.7%

-10.4%
-5.7%
-2.6%

Number of Comparisons
1
1

1
1

1
1
1

Mean Effect Size
-1.60 *
0.08 ns

0.11 ns
-0.08 ns

-0.20 ns
-0.16 ns
-0.21 ns

Bupropion short supine










Mean Baseline Value



28.10






Mean Percent Change



-42.7%






Number of Comparisons



1






Mean Effect Size



-1.99 *






Mirtazapine short supine










Mean Baseline Value
66.00
49.60



6.50


5.40

Mean Percent Change
15.29%
-35.7%



-21.5%


-25.9%

Number of Comparisons
1
1



1


1

Mean Effect Size
3.10 *
-2.47 *



-1.81 *


-3.97 *

ECT short supine










Mean Baseline Value




548.00

264.00



Mean Percent Change




-42.9%

50.4%



Number of Comparisons




1

1



Mean Effect Size




-0.88 ns

0.84 ns



ECT 24 h










Mean Baseline Value

69.65







8.64
Mean Percent Change

6.2%







34.3%
Number of Comparisons

1







1
Mean Effect Size

0.51 ns







0.90 ns

All treatments on this table are represented by only one study except ECT where the two studies employed different recording times.

ns indicates that original study or our reanalysis showed the change as non-significant, * indicates that the original study reported that the change was significant (p < .05).

van Zyl et al. BioPsychoSocial Medicine 2008 2:12   doi:10.1186/1751-0759-2-12

Open Data